Our People
Paper star
Cutting Through Complexity

OH, OH, OH, I Don’t Feel So Well

13th December 2013

Everyone gets unwell from time to time, but persistent short-term absence and long-term absence can cause real problems in the workplace. You employ individual members of staff for a good reason and when they’re not there, the carefully oiled and calibrated machine which is your organisation is liable to seize up.

After a while you may have a situation up with which you cannot put (to misquote something Churchill probably never said), but it’s not simply a matter of getting rid of the absent employee and replacing them with another. Although capability (in this case incapability due to ill-health) is one of the potentially fair reasons for dismissal, case law has held that when dealing with sickness absence, "sympathy, understanding and compassion" is the order of the day. And of course, you may have a duty to make reasonable adjustments if the employee is disabled under the Equality Act 2010.

In the first instance and amongst other things, you’ll need to ascertain the nature of the employee's illness, the prospects of the employee returning to work and the likelihood of the recurrence of the illness. In order to do so, you will need to obtain an up-to-date medical opinion and this is commonly done by obtaining an occupational health (OH) report. But as any decision made by the employer (to dismiss or otherwise) is a managerial one, not a medical one, how far can you rely on the report?

In the recent case of Gallop v Newport City Council, the Court of Appeal held that it is no defence to a disability discrimination claim to ‘unquestioningly’ accept the opinion of an OH practitioner that an employee is not disabled. Although at the end of the day only an Employment Tribunal can determine whether an employee is disabled, a reasonable employer must make up its own mind on this issue based on the facts presented to it.

Top tip this week is therefore to ask an OH adviser a series of specific questions focussed on the particular circumstances of the employee’s medical condition. The OH response will then help the employer decide whether it considers the employee to be disabled. Without doing so, an employer could never assert ignorance (on the basis that it did not know and could not reasonably have been expected to know that an employee is disabled).

And once you have that report, do remember that consulting with the employee must be your next step. They must have the opportunity to comment, suggest and challenge the report and your proposed reaction to its content. In the absence of consultation, the success of a claim for unfair dismissal and possibly disability discrimination will be almost guaranteed.

The contents of this update are intended as guidance for readers. It can be no substitute for specific advice. Consequently we cannot accept responsibility for this information, errors or matters affected by subsequent changes in the law, or the content of any website referred to in this update. © Mundays LLP 2013.

Latest News

Gross Misconduct and Statutory Notice
Thursday 12th July 2018

Sophie Banks looks back at a recent bulletin and the EAT judgement handed down last week

Read More

Directors’ Addresses – Privacy Extended
Friday 6th July 2018

Fiona Moss describes the proposals to allow removal of historic personal information from Companies House as identity theft increases and data privacy hits headlines

Read More

The long-term funding of adult social care
Friday 29th June 2018

Howard White provides an update on the joint report from the Health and Social Care and Housing, Communities and Local Government Committees on the long-term funding of adult social care

Read More